We frequently read the misguided view that people who are going to be paying 40% tax in retirement should not bother paying into a pension through additional voluntary contributions (AVCs) since they won’t receive any benefit.
Misunderstandings about two different types of tax rates often create confusion in discussions about taxes. A taxpayer’s average tax rate (or effective tax rate) is the share of income that he or she pays in taxes. By contrast, a taxpayer’s marginal tax rate is the tax rate imposed on his or her last euro of income.
In Ireland, a Taxpayers’ average tax rates are lower — usually much lower — than their marginal rates. People who confuse the two can end up thinking that taxes are much higher than they actually are.
Ireland has a progressive tax system, marginal rates of tax rise progressively as income increases
Contrast this with Investment tax (Exit Tax) which is a flat rate of 41% at all income levels
Current Income Tax Budget 2020 (including PRSI and USC) vs Exit Tax
We can see that compared to Exit Tax which is always applied at a flat 41% with no reliefs available, Income Tax is a progressive tax and PAYE workers in Ireland don’t pay an effective rate of tax higher than the current rate of Exit Tax on household incomes under €120,000 and for a couple with two incomes the breakeven point is considerably higher.
We can see that given a choice between more pension income or investment income in retirement, retirees should conclude that it is only very high earners who will potentially benefit from investment taxation at Exit Tax rates.
Why is the average tax rate generally much lower than the marginal tax rate?
In the graph above we can see that a married couple with two incomes with an income of €60,000 faces a top marginal tax rate of 40% plus PRSI and USC, so they would commonly be referred to as “being in the 40 percent bracket.” But their average tax rate — the share of their salary that they pay in taxes — is only 15 percent, as explained below.
Example to explain why the effective rate of tax is lower than the marginal rate of taxation
1. Because of deductions, not all income is subject to taxation
In the example above, the couple can each claim personal tax credits totalling €6,600 pa in the tax year 2020. Subtracting that from the couple’s tax liability is providing tax relief at the marginal rate of 40%.
2. The top marginal tax rate applies only to a portion of taxable income
As the analysis above shows, because both partners have an income, they are making effective use of their 20% tax bands, in this example none of their income is subject to 40% tax.
For these taxpayers, their total deductions amount to €8,805 on gross taxable income of €60,000 an effective rate of tax of just 14.675%
What is the impact of making a €10,000 AVC ?
We can see that the deductions now reduce to €6,805 for the tax year 2020 an effective rate of tax on gross taxable income of just 11.34% with a tax refund due to the taxpayer of €2,000.
We can see that even through this family is “only” receiving 20% tax relief on their pension contribution, it is still an effective way of saving for retirement.
For a more detailed analysis, please see our guide here